This is one of those poems, like R.S. Thomas' "Song at the Year's Turning," that I can't really figure out but love very much anyway. I love "fisted flex of heart." Also how "staring staring silence" is revisited later with the "Unwinking eyes of saints" and "I felt the Churcheyed, fidget fear." I love the structure of the three long sentences that make up the three stanzas, and the tone of frustration, perhaps tinged with surrender. Perhaps not tinged with surrender. I'm not really sure. I like the outraged shock in the question of the title. Is it outraged shock? Is it a sort of mocking of teenage petulance? There's some kind of returning going on, but is it to an emotion? Or a place? And if it's to a place, is it a physical place or a spiritual one? Maybe it's all of these things. Or none of them. I can't really figure it out. But still I love this poem by the Irishman, Desmond O'Grady, which I found in his 1967 collection called The Dark Edge of Europe.
Was
I Supposed to Know?
When,
In a
blue-sharp, fallow sky,
With
wind in hair
And
grey of rock, angled by ages, sharpening the eye,
I
Stamped
down that cut stone stair
Towards
sand and sea
And
clawed, nails scratching, down from the deaf-mute cliffs to where
Were
track and trees below --
Was I
supposed to know?
When,
With
senses quick as compass
And
tightened skin,
In
breaking clearing, fell on Church and Churchyard moss
I,
Helpless,
toeheeled in
To
Christ and Cross
And
staring staring silence, felt small as a pin,
Felt
schoolboy years ago --
Was I
supposed to know?
Was I
supposed to know
That
each fisted flex of heart
And
wide of eye,
Each
pitch of thought in bone-sprung skull; each stutter start
Of
unravelled blood in my
Knit
flesh and bone;
And
every studied part I cast me as a boy;
That
all my rebel scorn
And
mock at prayer,
My
every bedded bitch and spilled out kids unborn,
Were
All
marked mine with care --
By
some high Law
Or
some high guiding Plan -- to lead me back to where,
Again,
With
coffin smell of pew
And
chris of Cross,
Unwinking
eyes of saints and hushed confession queue --
For
one loud nervous boot
Of
frightened heart,
I felt
the Churcheyed, fidget fear of schooltied youth?